Why the MacBook Neo Might Not Be a Windows Laptop Replacement

We may earn a commission from links on this page.

The MacBook Neo seems to be anything anyone in the tech world can talk about this week. Apple somehow made a MacBook that does just about everything you want a MacBook to do, all for $599 ($499 with an education discount). That price point makes Apple's next-cheapest computer, the MacBook Air, seem borderline unreasonable for $1,099.

MacBook Neo

$599.00 at Amazon

Shop Now

Shop Now

$599.00 at Amazon

Part of what's fueling the hype here is how much the MacBook Neo could disrupt the budget and midrange laptop markets. Why spend $200 or $300 on a Chromebook when for a bit more, you could have a near-complete macOS experience? In the same vein, if you're turned off by Windows' insistence on unnecessary AI features and aggressive ads, but avoided Macs because of their high price tags, the Neo could turn you away from PC. In fact, much of the discussion around the Neo is how this might finally be the midrange Windows laptop replacement the market has been looking for.

But a $499 MacBook isn't without compromises. The Neo has certain limitations you might not be used to from Apple's usual Macs, or from your Windows PC: There's only 8GB of RAM, even if you pay for the model with 512GB of storage; the keyboard doesn't have a backlight; and the USB-C ports are older, which means you can't charge as fast as other devices, or transfer data as quickly.

But if you're coming from a Windows machine, and you're used to a certain way of doing things, you might be thinking: Can the MacBook Neo run Windows? The answer, it seems, is yes—but you probably shouldn't buy it for that.

The MacBook Neo isn't the perfect Windows replacement

First things first: the MacBook Neo can't run Windows natively. Those days are long behind us, once Apple switched from Intel chips to its own ARM-based Apple silicon. Intel Macs have "Boot Camp," which can install Windows directly onto a partition of the machine. With Apple silicon Macs, you need to use a third-party program to run Windows in a virtual machine.

One such program is Parallels, long an option for Mac users looking to run Windows while still having ready access to macOS. As it happens, Parallels confirmed the MacBook Neo is compatible with its application, which means the computer's A18 Pro chip can handle running Windows in a virtual machine. Problem solved, right?

Unfortunately, no. While Windows will run in Parallels on MacBook Neo, it might not be an ideal experience for many PC users. That's directly from Parallels itself, which commented: "For light, occasional Windows use, like a legacy business tool, or a Windows-only utility, MacBook Neo may provide an acceptable experience. For CPU- or GPU-intensive Windows applications, this computer is not the right choice."

Part of the issue is that the virtual machine running Windows 11 requires at least 4GB of RAM. The MacBook Neo is locked at 8GB, which doesn't leave much room for macOS. Parallels runs concurrently with macOS, since it runs Windows 11 in its own window. It's like if Windows 11 was an app on your Mac, alongside Safari, Messages, or Mail. Once you start running too much at once, you could easily choke your machine.

If you need to run Windows, consider these cheap laptops

If you don't really care about Windows support, and you're just looking for a capable laptop at that $500 or $600 price point, then the MacBook Neo could definitely replace a comparable Windows machine. It'll also runs Microsoft apps that have Mac support, like Word, PowerPoint, and Teams. But I wouldn't recommend it for users looking for something that also runs Windows, and the Windows-only programs they're used to. If that sounds like you, you might want to look at budget and midrange Windows laptops, like the Acer Aspire 3 or Acer Aspire 16.

If you still want both Windows and macOS access, consider a different MacBook. At that Neo price point, you could find an M1 MacBook Air with 16GB of RAM. The Neo actually outperforms the M1 in some ways, but that extra RAM will help you run Windows better in Parallels.

View the full article