How SEO leaders can explain agentic AI to ecommerce executives

Agentic AI is increasingly appearing in leadership conversations, often accompanied by big claims and unclear expectations. For SEO leaders working with ecommerce brands, this creates a familiar challenge.

Executives hear about autonomous agents, automated purchasing, and AI-led decisions, and they want to know what this really means for growth, risk, and competitiveness.

What they don’t need is more hype. They need clear explanations, grounded thinking, and practical guidance. 

This is where SEO leaders can add real value, not by predicting the future, but by helping leadership understand what is changing, what isn’t, and how to respond without overreacting. Here’s how.

Start by explaining what ‘agentic’ actually means

A useful first step is to remove the mystery from the term itself. Agentic systems don’t replace customers, they act on behalf of customers. The intent, preferences, and constraints still come from a person.

What changes is who does the work.

Discovery, comparison, filtering, and sometimes execution are handled by software that can move faster and process more information than a human can.

When speaking to executive teams, a simple framing works best:

• “We’re not losing customers, we’re adding a new decision-maker into the journey. That decision-maker is software acting as a proxy for the customer.” 

Once this is clear, the conversation becomes calmer and more practical, and the focus moves away from fear and toward preparation.

Keep expectations realistic and avoid the hype

Another important role for SEO leaders is to slow the conversation down. Agentic behavior will not arrive everywhere at the same time. Its impact will be uneven and gradual.

Some categories will see change earlier because their products are standardized and data is already well structured. Others will move more slowly because trust, complexity, or regulation makes automation harder.

This matters because leadership teams often fall into one of two traps:

1. Panic, where plans are rewritten too quickly, budgets move too fast, and teams chase futures that may still be some distance away. 
2. Dismissal, where nothing changes until performance clearly drops, and by then the response is rushed.

SEO leaders can offer a steadier view. Agentic AI accelerates trends that already exist. Personalized discovery, fewer visible clicks, and more pressure on data quality are not new problems. 

Agents simply make them more obvious. Seen this way, agentic AI becomes a reason to improve foundations, not a reason to chase novelty.

Dig deeper: Are we ready for the agentic web?

Change the conversation from rankings to eligibility

One of the most helpful shifts in executive conversations is moving away from rankings as the main outcome of SEO. In an agent-led journey, the key question isn’t “do we rank well?” but “are we eligible to be chosen at all?”

Eligibility depends on clarity, consistency, and trust. An agent needs to understand what you sell, who it is for, how much it costs, whether it is available, and how risky it is to choose you on behalf of a user. This is a strong way to connect SEO to commercial reality.

Questions worth raising include whether product information is consistent across systems, whether pricing and availability are reliable, and whether policies reduce uncertainty or create it. Framed this way, SEO becomes less about chasing traffic and more about making the business easy to select.

Explain why SEO no longer sits only in marketing

Many executives still see SEO as a marketing channel, but agentic behavior challenges that view.

Selection by an agent depends on factors that sit well beyond marketing. Data quality, technical reliability, stock accuracy, delivery performance, and payment confidence all play a role.

SEO leaders should be clear about this. This isn’t about writing more content. It’s about making sure the business is understandable, reliable, and usable by machines.

Positioned correctly, SEO becomes a connecting function that helps leadership see where gaps in systems or data could prevent the brand from being selected. This often resonates because it links SEO to risk and operational health, not just growth.

Dig deeper: How to integrate SEO into your broader marketing strategy

Be clear that discovery will change first

For most ecommerce brands, the earliest impact of agentic systems will be at the top of the funnel. Discovery becomes more conversational and more personal.

Users describe situations, needs, and constraints instead of typing short search phrases, and the agent then turns that context into actions.

This reduces the value of simply owning category head terms. If an agent knows a user’s budget, preferences, delivery expectations, and past behavior, it doesn’t behave like a first-time visitor. It behaves like a well-informed repeat customer.

This creates a reporting challenge. Some SEO work will no longer look like direct demand creation, even though it still influences outcomes. Leadership teams need to be prepared for this shift.

---

Reframe consideration as filtering, not persuasion

The middle of the funnel also changes shape. Today, consideration often involves reading reviews, comparing options, and seeking reassurance.

In an agent-led journey, consideration becomes a filtering process, where the agent removes options it believes the user would reject and keeps those that fit.

This has clear implications. Generic content becomes less effective as a traffic driver because agents can generate summaries and comparisons instantly. Trust signals become structural, meaning claims need to be backed by consistent and verifiable information.

In many cases, a brand may be chosen without the user being consciously aware of it. That can be positive for conversion, but risky for long-term brand strength if recognition isn’t built elsewhere.

Dig deeper: How to align your SEO strategy with the stages of buyer intent

Set honest expectations about measurement

Executives care about measurement, and agentic AI makes this harder. As more discovery and consideration happen inside AI systems, fewer interactions leave clean attribution trails. Some impact will show up as direct traffic, and some will not be visible at all.

SEO leaders should address this early. This isn’t a failure of optimization. It reflects the limits of today’s analytics in a more mediated world.

The conversation should move toward directional signals and blended performance views, rather than precise channel attribution that no longer reflects how decisions are made.

Promote a proactive, low-risk response

The most important part of the leadership discussion is what to do next. The good news is that most sensible responses to agentic AI are low risk.

Improving product data quality, reducing inconsistencies across platforms, strengthening reliability signals, and fixing technical weaknesses all help today, regardless of how quickly agents mature.

Investing in brand demand outside search also matters. If agents handle more of the comparison work, brands that users already trust by name are more likely to be selected.

This reassures leaders that action doesn’t require dramatic change, only disciplined improvement.

Agentic AI changes the focus, not the fundamentals

For SEO leaders, agentic AI changes the focus of the role. The work shifts from optimizing pages to protecting eligibility, from chasing visibility to reducing ambiguity, and from reporting clicks to explaining influence.

This requires confidence, clear communication, and a willingness to challenge hype. Agentic AI makes SEO more strategic, not any less important.

Agentic AI should not be treated as an immediate threat or a guaranteed advantage. It’s a shift in how decisions are made.

For ecommerce brands, the winners will be those that stay calm, communicate clearly, and adapt their SEO thinking from driving clicks to earning selection.

That is the conversation SEO leaders should be having now.

Dig deeper: The future of search visibility: What 6 SEO leaders predict for 2026

View the full article